Updated November 20, 2026. Listing data as of November 20, 2026; prices checked on November 20, 2026.
This week the best-priced homes in Surprise are listed about 33%–39% below recent nearby sales per square foot, at about $133–$142/sq ft compared with a citywide median of $221. The #1 home, 17168 W Running Deer Trl in Desert Oasis Phase 2 Parcel, is listed at $475,000, down $84,000 from its original price.
Surprise market notes
- Market snapshot: 1,772 closed sales (1,500+ sq ft) from May 20 to November 20, 2026; citywide median sold price $221.25/sq ft. This week's 5 homes list at about $133–$142/sq ft, 33%–39% below their comps.
- Lifestyle: Surprise Stadium (Rangers and Royals spring training), Surprise Recreation Campus and aquatic center, and Prasada shopping. Loop 303 access, with White Tank Mountain Regional Park nearby.
- Long-term outlook: Prasada East is planned with a 35,000 sq ft Whole Foods, and a 16-acre retail project at Cactus Rd and Cotton Ln and Elm Street at Surprise City Center are also coming.
This week’s top 5 Surprise home deals
Photos and live details for this week’s five homes.
#1Deal Score: 92.8
17168 W Running Deer Trl, Surprise, AZ 85387
List price: $475,000 · Originally $559,000, down $84,000
- 5 bedrooms
- 3 full baths
- 3,381 sq ft
- Lot: 6,875 sq ft (0.16 acres)
- Built in 2022
- 2-story
- Pool: none
- HOA: $100/mo
- Days on market: 248 (as of November 20, 2026)
- Price per sq ft: $140 vs. $215 for recent comparable sales
- About 35% below comps
Why it’s worth a look: Listed at about $140 per sq ft, roughly 35% below recent Desert Oasis Phase 2 Parcel sales ($215/sq ft). Down $84,000 (15.0%) from its original price. On the market 248 days.
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty.
#2Deal Score: 85.1
17023 W Ipswitch Way, Surprise, AZ 85374
List price: $399,900 · Originally $429,900, down $30,000
- 4 bedrooms
- 3 full baths
- 3,009 sq ft
- Lot: 6,900 sq ft (0.16 acres)
- Built in 2005
- 2-story
- Pool: none
- HOA: $72/mo
- Days on market: 43 (as of November 20, 2026)
- Price per sq ft: $133 vs. $216 for recent comparable sales
- About 38% below comps
Why it’s worth a look: Listed at about $133 per sq ft, roughly 38% below recent Bell West Ranch West Parcel 3 sales ($216/sq ft). Down $30,000 (7.0%) from its original price.
Listing courtesy of Congress Realty, Inc..
#3Deal Score: 84.3
15546 W Gelding Dr, Surprise, AZ 85379
List price: $499,900 · Originally $515,000, down $15,100
- 4 bedrooms
- 2 full + 1 half baths
- 3,659 sq ft
- Lot: 7,154 sq ft (0.16 acres)
- Built in 2002
- 2-story
- Pool: none
- HOA: $48.33/mo
- Days on market: 105 (as of November 20, 2026)
- Price per sq ft: $137 vs. $224 for recent comparable sales
- About 39% below comps
Why it’s worth a look: Listed at about $137 per sq ft, roughly 39% below recent Greenway Parc At Surprise 2 sales ($224/sq ft). Down $15,100 (2.9%) from its original price. On the market 105 days.
Listing courtesy of HomeSmart.
#4Deal Score: 81.1
24081 N 163rd Dr, Surprise, AZ 85387
List price: $500,000 · Originally $550,000, down $50,000
- 4 bedrooms
- 3 full baths
- 3,562 sq ft
- Lot: 7,498 sq ft (0.17 acres)
- Built in 2009
- 2-story
- Pool: none
- HOA: $94/mo
- Days on market: 171 (as of November 20, 2026)
- Price per sq ft: $140 vs. $210 for recent comparable sales
- About 33% below comps
Why it’s worth a look: Listed at about $140 per sq ft, roughly 33% below recent Asante Phase 1 Unit 1 sales ($210/sq ft). Down $50,000 (9.1%) from its original price. On the market 171 days.
Listing courtesy of Realty Executives Arizona Territory.
#5Deal Score: 80.2
17873 W Watson Ln, Surprise, AZ 85388
List price: $474,900 · Originally $500,000, down $25,100
- 5 bedrooms
- 3 full baths
- 3,336 sq ft
- Lot: 7,068 sq ft (0.16 acres)
- Built in 2004
- 2-story
- Pool: none
- HOA: $70/mo
- Days on market: 116 (as of November 20, 2026)
- Price per sq ft: $142 vs. $221 for recent comparable sales
- About 36% below comps
Why it’s worth a look: Listed at about $142 per sq ft, roughly 36% below the Surprise median ($221/sq ft). Down $25,100 (5.0%) from its original price. On the market 116 days.
Listing courtesy of Realty of America LLC.
Surprise home deal questions
What is the median price per square foot in Surprise, AZ?
Surprise's citywide median sold price was $221.25 per square foot across 1,772 closed single-family sales of 1,500+ sq ft from May 20 to November 20, 2026. This week's five Best List homes are listed at about $133 to $142 per square foot.
Are home prices dropping in Surprise?
This week's data doesn't measure a citywide price trend, but every home on this week's Surprise list has been reduced from its original asking price. The cuts range from $15,100 to $84,000, and the largest is on 17168 W Running Deer Trl.
How long have this week's best-priced Surprise homes been on the market?
They've been on the market between 43 and 248 days as of November 20, 2026. The longest, 17168 W Running Deer Trl in Desert Oasis Phase 2 Parcel, has been listed 248 days and has had an $84,000 price cut.
How far below market are the best home deals in Surprise?
This week's five homes are listed about 33% to 39% below the six-month median sold price per square foot for their subdivisions, or Surprise's citywide median where subdivision sales were limited. The top-ranked home, 17168 W Running Deer Trl, is about 35% below recent Desert Oasis Phase 2 Parcel sales.
More from Bender’s Best List
- Bender’s Best List: this week’s best home deals in every city on the list
- How the Deal Score works
- Surprise, AZ communities and neighborhood guides
Call Wes Text Wes





